Life Insurance at 100

August 15th, 2017 No comments

Different Policies Have Different Features

When it rains it pours. I have multiple cases on my desk now regarding age 100 and/or “endow-ment” issues. Also, recently a Wall Street Journal addressed this same issue.

Historically most policy owners didn’t concern themselves too much about what happens when an insured individual turns 100 years old. This is partly because most people didn’t expect to live to 100 and partly because people didn’t know there was anything to concern themselves with. However, it seems to be on people’s minds more often lately.

Current Mindset

For a recent insurance portfolio I helped to construct, the decision was made to go with a blend-ed portfolio of guaranteed universal life insurance (GUL) and an indexed policy (IUL). The GUL was guaranteed for life and the IUL was guaranteed past life expectancy but not for life. How-ever, it was critically important to the trustee to extend the guarantees as the insured’s father lived into his nineties and his mother is still living in her late nineties. Even a guarantee to age 105 with projections at reasonable rates lasting forever wasn’t enough so we went further. I get it, especially when you are the trustee.

Whole Life at 100

The CFO of a family owned company recently engaged my services because the whole life policies owned by the children on the life of the family matriarch endow at age 100. Mom is turning 100 later this year. What does this mean? If the policy doesn’t have an extended maturity option (and this one doesn’t) the policy will mature and pay out at age 100. In a whole life policy, the cash value and the death benefit equal each other at age 100 so what’s the big issue? Taxes. At death the entire amount is tax free but a policy which pays out during life at policy maturity is taxable above basis. Most of the cash value is over basis.

If I make up a scenario and assume the cash value is $1,000,000 and the basis is $400,000 then $600,000 is taxable with a tax likely in excess of $200,000. We still have at least three quarters of the money available. This is clearly a disappointment but at least all is not lost.

However, in the above referenced situation, the $1,000,000 policy was sold on a short pay for 10 years and for the past 20 years the contract has been auto loaning itself the premium (unbeknownst to the policy owner which is par for the course). So? The loan is now $1,400,000. Gross cash value is $1,792,000. Basis is $800,000. This leaves about $1,000,000 taxable at ordinary rates. Taxes in this situation will be roughly $400,000 to be paid from the net cash value of $392,000,000 leaving the family with nothing. Yes, the entire forgiven loan is considered taxable income. If she passed away, the loan is paid off by the death benefit leaving them about a $600,000 death benefit. In and of itself, that would be disappointing as they purchased a $1,000,000 death benefit which they conservatively expected to grow over time. Actually, it did grow but the loan grew even faster which ate into the expected death benefit.

Earlier this week an attorney emailed me a statement on another whole life policy in a similar situation. When the policy lapses the taxes will far exceed the net cash value and the policy owner will have to come out of pocket to pay off the IRS for the taxes on the phantom gain.

Universal Life at Maturity

A case from a CPA involved a Universal Life contract. UL polices don’t technically endow in the sense that whole life policies do but they can have their own issues. There are multiple genera-tions of UL contracts and you can be pretty much assured your clients do not know which one they have. Some UL policies pay out the cash value at policy maturity and sometimes that is before age 100. If your client has a $5,000,000 policy and they are lucky enough to reach age 100 and the cash value is $500,000, they get a check for $500,000 with anything over basis taxed at ordinary rates.

Policies a generation newer take the cash value at maturity and extend it as the new death bene-fit. If your client’s $5,000,000 policy has $500,000 of cash value at age 100 then the policy will move forward with a $500,000 death benefit. However, due to a 35 year declining interest rate market, most of these policies are woefully underperforming and many will not hit age 100 with-out additional funding. The problem is, funding an underfunded policy to have cash value equal the death benefit at policy maturity is generally an untenable exercise. And if you do dramatical-ly increase the funding and the insured passes away at 95, the death benefit is no higher and all of the dollars are wasted. These are tough decisions.

With some policies, at least if you made it to 100 then the policy stayed in force until death, re-gardless of age. Many of them also did not have premiums and expenses after age 100 so once you hit 100 you were home free. Nowadays, policy maturity is more likely age 120 or beyond but you have to choose how long to fund it. Do you automatically fund for life instead of age 110? If the premium is negligibly different then of course you do. Some policies have a mean-ingful spread in premium for guarantees for life, to age 110, 105, 100, etc. Where is your com-fort level?

Decisions Need to be Made

These are damned if you do, damned if you don’t scenarios at times. I was working with the family of a 90 year old woman with a $10,000,000 policy with a few million of cash value. The existing cash value projected to hold the policy for 5 years then the contract would lapse. This means the cash value is dropping by hundreds of thousands of dollars a year. To hold the policy to age 100 would take a low seven figures of premium but if she hit 100 it would still all be lost. Holding the full death benefit beyond 100 would take millions more. Do you cut and run today, taking the remaining cash value and saving millions in premiums when she could pass away by Christmas and you lose the $10,000,000 in tax free death benefit? Paying the entire required premium for the full death benefit to persist beyond age 100 would leave you a relatively small spread between payments and payoff. Objective analysis can help with these decisions.

Regarding extended maturity options, some contracts have them but they are not automatically included and the policy owner has to overtly request them. Sometimes this is purportedly a letter which will be sent to the policy owner 30-90 days prior to maturity. This is insane! I have every bill in my life on auto pay because, though I am generally a responsible guy, my life is compli-cated enough that there can be no expectation that I will remember everything every month. Now imagine throwing in a literal once-in-a- lifetime decision that you were not expecting, do not understand and will probably not address in time.

I recently had such a case on an individual in her eighties. I told her son to write the letter re-questing the extension now, file a copy of it, and send the same letter every five years so if the policy owner doesn’t notice and act during the short window there will be a paper trail of intent and directive. I can’t guarantee what will happen but it certainly can’t hurt.

Bottom Line

Your clients need to understand things that they most definitely do not understand at this mo-ment. They will be blindsided without your heads up. Help them however you can.

Categories: Life Insurance Tags:

How Do Professional Group Term Contracts Stack Up

August 7th, 2017 No comments

If you’re a professional, chances are you’ve looked at group term rates through a professional association. For example, many CPAs have their term insurance through the American Institute of CPAs (AICPA) which has served many people well over the years. However, I like to say that there is a difference between having something done and having it done as well as it can be. Being informed can pay off. For full post, click here…

Categories: Life Insurance Tags:

The True Meaning of the S&P 500 Index

July 19th, 2017 No comments

DECK: It may not be what you think

Have you ever heard something often enough that you take it for fact but you don’t really under-stand what it means? What if I told you the S&P 500 Index wasn’t really what you thought it was? Would you believe me versus everything you ever understood it to be? Probably not. For full post, click here…

Categories: Life Insurance Tags:

Is Term Insurance a Commodity?

July 13th, 2017 No comments

Hopefully the message that life insurance cannot be treated as a commodity is slowly getting through to advisors and consumers. I see signs here and there that it is but it seems to be a painfully slow process.

Even when that realization sets in, the perception of term insurance is often different. I have to admit that I haven’t always viewed the details of term insurance on par with permanent insurance but there are aspects to keep in mind which may not surface for years to come. For full post, click here…

Categories: Life Insurance Tags:

AALU Piece: Avoiding 5 Common Mistakes in Life Insurance Planning

June 15th, 2017 No comments
TOPIC: “Trouble Ahead, Trouble Behind,” and You Know that Notion Never Crossed My Mind: Avoiding 5 Common Mistakes in Life Insurance Planning.

As estate planning involving personal life insurance becomes commoditized, so does the chance that a minor oversight will have a major tax impact.

SYNOPSIS: According to experts, some of the most common mistakes in life insurance planning include: (1) failure to qualify gifts to irrevocable life insurance trust (“ILITs”) for the annual gift tax exclusion; (2) improper allocation of GST tax exemption to ILIT gifts; (3) retention of incidents of ownership in an ILIT – owned policy; (4) failure to understand the planning implications of a policy classification as a modified endowment contract; and (5) triggering tax on an otherwise non – taxable policy exchange under Internal Revenue Code (“Code”) §1035. Find out how to identify and avoid them. For full post, click here…

Categories: Life Insurance Tags:

OC Consulting Group – What’s it about?

May 23rd, 2017 No comments

Categories: Life Insurance Tags:

Timing of Premium Payments

May 11th, 2017 No comments

AIn my May 12th, 2015 post, Why Paying Attention is Important, I referenced a hypothetical issue which has just come across my desk in real life. It has to do with a Guaranteed Universal Life (GUL) policy and the timing of premiums.

Much has been made of the sensitivity of GUL contracts to the timing of premiums, and for good reason.success-stories-logo Many policies do not have the grace periods of more traditional policies. A premium which comes in late, may slightly affect the internal formulas which determine the guarantees and, consequently, the policy may not last as long as expected. For full post, click here…

Categories: Success Stories Tags:

Insurance By The Numbers

May 4th, 2017 No comments

Help Your Clients Understand What They Are Really Getting For Their Money

Have you ever been talking with someone intelligent who says something which makes you do a double take? I’m talking about the kind of thing which makes you assume you have misheard them because no one could really think that.

Here’s a case in point I often hear in reference to funding a traditional whole life policy. “I keep paying the premium, even though I don’t have to, because it grows the cash value so much.” What’s so crazy about this comment? For full post, click here…

Categories: Life Insurance Tags:

Success Story: Life Settlement Saves the Day

April 18th, 2017 No comments

The life settlement market is clearly much different than it was 10 years ago but it is still alive and well. The target for finding a qualifying policy is much smaller today but the parameters were likely somewhat unrealistic back then anyway.

Settlements still tend to be success-stories-logosomewhat controversial but with a straight face I will say that I cannot understand why. A legitimate, well understood life settlement is arguably the most consumer beneficial concept I have ever been a part of in my history in the life insurance market. The many, many millions of dollars I have been able to secure for clients who otherwise would have lost millions is astounding. For full post, click here…

Categories: Success Stories Tags:

Giving a Life Insurance Policy to Charity

April 11th, 2017 No comments

Over the past number of months I’ve had a handful of cases come across my desk involving life insurance and charity. As is so often the case, some of the transactions ended up as case stud-ies in what to watch out for.

I understand that not everyone is going to have the same attitude regarding the intersection of life insurance and the non-profit sector but I am somewhat surprised at the black and white policies of charitable organizations I encounter at times. Many charities and non-profits have a policy to simply cash out life insurance policies which are donated. I can’t think of a more short sighted stance. Of course each and every transaction should be evaluated on it’s own merits relative to required premiums, guarantees, life expectancy, use of money, etc. It also doesn’t help that so many non-profits have been burned by life insurance over the years the same as so many consumers have. For full post, click here…

Categories: Life Insurance Tags: